I Choose Not to Wear a Mask

By | June 20, 2020

As a person fast approaching the magic “at risk” age, I choose to not wear a mask. I know that will drive some of my friends in larger urban areas absolutely nuts. Let me say up front that I am only talking about my decision, for me. I am not trying to tell you what you should do. I’m assuming, sometimes against evidence, that you have a brain and can make your own decision for what is best in your own life.

I will also admit that some of my friends, particularly those in large urban areas, will go nuts with this statement of decision. I expect to see vitriol in the comments on this post and on Facebook. So be it. Remember, though, I’m not telling you what you should do. I will respect your decision. If you find it impossible to respect mine, then perhaps you should look at your reaction to my decision instead of my actual decision.

I live in rural Wyoming, in Uinta County. As of this morning (June 20, 2020) our county has 103 laboratory-confirmed cases of COVID-19 out of an estimated population of 20,226. Of those 103 cases, 35 have been lab-confirmed as recovered. That’s an overall infection rate of 0.51% and a non-recovered infection rate of 0.33%. There are 0 deaths from COVID-19 in our county.

I should also point out that our county is sort of bifurcated. Well over half of the population lives 38 miles away, in Evanston, on the Wyoming/Utah border. That is where the vast majority of COVID-19 cases have been. We’ve had a few in Bridger Valley (where I live), but to the best of my knowledge you can count the number of cases on a single hand.

This is me, standing in the middle of Main Street (on the double-yellow line) at 5:35 pm on a recent Friday evening.

This is me, standing in the middle of Main Street (on the double-yellow line) at 5:35 pm on a recent Friday evening. It is not an understatement to say there is no rush hour in our town.

This is my reality. This is what I have lived with since the pandemic broke out. I don’t live in an urban area. We have no Wal-Mart or Piggly Wiggly nearby. There is one bar in my town, a block away, and I think over the past four months, I’ve only noticed one time when the number of patrons may have gotten above ten. We don’t even get the mail delivered to our house, for goodness sake. We are already, by all definitions, socially distanced. Always have been.

Yet, I have Facebook friends who make asinine comments regarding my decision not to wear a mask. Perhaps the most asinine is telling me that somehow, if I don’t wear a mask, I don’t care about others. I’ve heard it time and time again. Just yesterday I saw someone say “You wear a mask because you are considerate of others. Or you don’t. Because you’re not.”

I know that these people may be well-intentioned, but they really aren’t thinking before they speak. I know they cannot read minds, yet they are assigning motive to my actions. In other words, they are saying that because I don’t wear a mask, I am telling them — signaling to them — that I don’t care about them. They are telling me that they need me to signal, to them, my care and concern.

Well, let me tell you flat out. I do care. I am concerned. And I do not believe that I must wear a mask to signal that care and concern. If you decide you want to wear a mask, you go right ahead. It is supposedly still a free country, and I have no problem with you exercising that freedom, even though you may have a problem with me exercising mine.

Before you get all hot and bothered about my decision, let me point out that if my state, my county, or my town required the wearing of masks, I would do so. I believe in obeying the law, even ones I may disagree with. And when I travel to areas that require the wearing of masks, I will do so there because of the same belief. And if I want to do business with an establishment that requires the wearing of masks, I will wear one, again for the same belief. Likewise, if I came into your home and you wanted me to wear a mask while there, I would do so.

What I won’t do is wear a mask in public just because you believe I must do so. You are not in a position of authority over me, and until you are in such a position, I don’t have to listen to you any more than you have to listen to me. That is called freedom.

Now, I do want to address the science behind wearing or not wearing a mask. You see, I don’t want you to make the mistaken assumption that I choose not to wear one just because I live in an area where the coronavirus is virtually non-existent or because of a lack of government requirement or out of some philosophical exercise of personal freedom. In my personal decision-making process there is also a medical component.

To say that the debate regarding the efficacy of wearing masks is scientifically settled is, at best, premature; it isn’t settled. And, yes, I’ve seen all the cute memes and bumper-sticker statements of belief people post on Facebook. I’ve seen them both pro and con. They carry no weight, and I believe anyone who relies on them as a basis for their decision is shallow and, honestly, intellectually lazy—pro or con. They may make you feel good to post, but they don’t constitute a reasoned argument.

I also won’t generally listen to doctors on this matter for a very simple reason—there is no consensus. You can literally line up dozens of doctors who advocate for wearing masks and dozens who say it does no good. Literally. And where does that leave you? I’ll tell you where it leaves all of us—still with a personal choice to make.

Let me give you an analogous example. What do you do when you go to one doctor and he says “you need an operation?” Good practice says that you get a second opinion. So, you go to another doctor who says “you don’t need an operation.” What do you do then? You may go to a third, a fourth, a fifth, or as many doctors as you want. Why? To gather information so you can make your own decision. And then you make the best personal decision you can based on all the information available to you.

So, in the case of masks, I choose to skip the dueling doctors and go to the World Health Organization. To my understanding, they have access to the best and brightest in the world. According to them, in public advice given earlier this month (available here), they said “there is no direct evidence on the effectiveness of universal masking of healthy people in the community to prevent infection with respiratory viruses, including COVID-19.” The world’s premiere health organization flat-out says there is no direct evidence. None.

So, there you have it. My choosing to not wear a mask doesn’t mean I haven’t thought it through. I have, from multiple angles, and I hope you think through it, too. If you come to a different decision than I do, great. Don’t be a jerk, though, and tell someone they “don’t care” about others by not wearing a mask. That is a facile attempt at manipulation by guilt. I promise I won’t tell you that you are right or wrong in what is ultimately a personal decision, and I would appreciate it if you would do the same.

4 thoughts on “I Choose Not to Wear a Mask

  1. Misty

    Hi, Allen I’ve been researching the topic of mask wearing after an uncomfortable experience today. I’ve been in a group for over four years and the COVID situation has brought up some interesting topics. Masking wearing came up today, and I admitted I’m wearing a mask out of two reasons 1) Austin requires we wear them in businesses and 2) out of respect for others. I do occasionally feel it’s a good idea to wear a mask, but with rare exception, I am wearing a mask out of the fear that I will not be allow to buy food (or do necessary business transactions) or out of the fear that people will attack me (verbally, at least). Today when admitting this, it was asserted by a fellow group member that I don’t care about others. I tried to be calm and share this is absolutely not true, but inside I feel outrage.

    I read your blog and see you mentioned, “I do not believe that I must wear a mask to signal that care and concern.” I’m curious. I’m curious because I believe this at some level, too, but on another level I’m more afraid that I will be perceived in a bad light (uncaring, unhealthy, disrespectful, etc.) I’m curious how you have such confidence in this. I’m curious how you personally respond to others in a way that is respectful of their beliefs while also allowing for your own values and beliefs. I wonder how you respond to other people’s character assessments (or rather their character assassinations).

    These are interesting times, and I feel that I’m really stretching myself thin trying to remain respectful and kind to others when I do not feel my own concerns and beliefs are being treated respectfully in return. Thoughts?

    1. Allen Post author

      Thanks for your thoughtful comment, Misty.

      You ask how I “personally respond to others in a way that is respectful of their beliefs while also allowing for your own values and beliefs.” I think that one way of doing that is to put my thoughts on the matter down, on paper (so to speak), as I’ve tried to do in this post.

      I think we live in a time when (1) people are too quick to judge and (2) too quick to take offense. That is a potent combination, and it can lead to more misunderstanding than not. For instance, the other day I posted a link to this mask-related missive (above) on Facebook. Someone I know posted, in reply, that I was a sociopath. (His words, not mine.) It was obvious that he had not read my blog post, and if he had, he was too quick to judge and too quick to take offense.

      I cannot help such people; they are their own worst enemy and their judgemental behavior cannot make the world a better place.

      I’m rambling now, and I apologize for that. I wish you well in navigating these rough times.


  2. Simon Payton

    Allen, the quote from the WHO doesn’t say what you claim it does. When read in context, it’s saying masks haven’t been proven effective at preventing non-infected wearers from becoming infected. That said, there’s overwhelming evidence that masks help prevent the spread of the virus from already-infected people to others. That combined with the WHO’s statement that “80% of infections are mild or asymptomatic” means there are many people who have the virus and don’t know it. Those people pose a threat to everyone else—a threat that could be mitigated to an extent if they were wearing masks. I appreciate your desire for freedom, but you are stating your case using a poor interpretation of cherry-picked data.

    1. Allen Post author


      I appreciate your comment. I would also appreciate it if you don’t accuse me of cherry-picking data. You honed in on my one comment about the WHO and ignored my previous comments about lining up doctors both for and against. (Do you REALLY want to go through that. I don’t.)

      You also indicate that my case is a “desire for freedom” when that is not what my post expresses. When it comes to freedom, the only freedom I talk about is the freedom of an individual to make up his or her mind in the light of competing information for or against a proposition, in light of the circumstances in which one finds himself. I’m happy to allow you that freedom. Please allow me the same.


Comments are closed.